-
-
- Oct 26, 1997
-
- The Baltimore Sun [Front Page]
- Struggle: U.S. nuclear tests and Westernization have crippled the Marshall
- Islands, which has contracted the University of Maryland at Baltimore to
- recommend reforms.
-
- By Frank D. Roylance
-
- Sun Staff
-
- MAJURO, Republic of the Marshall Islands -- Nature blessed the Marshall
- Islands with warm Pacific breezes, tropical fruits, schooling fish and turquoise
- lagoons.
-
- But a half-century of U.S. control and influence here since World War II has
- cursed them with illness and crumbling medical care.
-
- The Marshallese still live with the contamination, illness, displacement,
- dependency and fear brought on by U.S. nuclear tests in the 1940s and 1950s
- -- 67 blasts with a total power 7,000 times that unleashed on Hiroshima,
- Japan, in wartime.
-
- But even more devastating have been dietary and lifestyle changes, cultural and
- economic disruptions caused by rapid Westernization of the Marshalls -- first
- as a United Nations trustee under U.S. administration, and later as an
- independent country under America's financial and military wing. These
- changes have brought the islanders premature old age, soaring cancer death
- rates, and more diabetes than in almost any place in the world.
-
- "The entire situation of the Marshallese is quite unfortunate," said Col. Richard
- Chapman, a retired former U.S. Army commander at the Kwajalein Atoll
- missile range, who developed an affection for the islands and their people.
- "They embraced a good deal of what's wrong with our culture, and lost a great
- deal of what was good in theirs."
-
- Struggling to address its health care crisis, the Marshallese government signed
- a $40,000 contract last year with the University of Maryland, Baltimore to
- study the country's medical system. UMAB physicians visited the islands'
- hospitals and clinics, performed 48 eye surgeries and recommended reforms.
-
- The islands face enormous problems that affect public health.
-
- Lured by paychecks from the U.S. Army or the U.S.-financed Marshallese
- government, nearly two-thirds of the country's 60,000 people have crowded
- into urban settlements on just two islands -- Majuro and Ebeye. Those who
- find jobs are joined by relatives who come to share the income.
-
- On overcrowded Ebeye, failing water, electric and sewer systems have led to
- outbreaks of gastrointestinal illness that killed four children over four months
- earlier this year, and sickened more.
-
- The pursuit of cash and consumer goods, and disruption of traditional family and
- community life, are also blamed for crime, spousal abuse, drug abuse, truancy,
- teen pregnancy and suicide.
-
- The traditional diet of fish and tropical fruits and vegetables has been largely
- supplanted by the worst of the West's culinary exports. Spam and frozen
- turkey tails are favorites, as are other convenience foods high in fat, salt and
- sugar, and low in nutrition.
-
- Among the consequences: Twenty percent of preschoolers are malnourished
- and 38 percent are anemic. Half of the adult women are overweight. Thirty
- percent of the people over age 15 suffer from non-insulin-dependent diabetes,
- resulting in high rates of hypertension, cardiovascular disease, kidney and eye
- disease.
-
- "It really is a disaster," said Dr. Paul Z. Zimmet, of the International Diabetes
- Institute in Caulfield, Australia who has studied diabetes in the Pacific islands.
-
- There's more. Forty years of U.S. administration as part of the former U.S.
- Trust Territory of the Pacific, and nearly a billion dollars in U.S. aid since
- independence in 1986, have left the Marshallese with a American-style health
- care system they have not been able to maintain, and which does not keep them
- healthy.
-
- For example, $8 million, U.S.-funded hospital on Majuro is literally dissolving
- in the salt air and tropical rains. The roof leaks, and the walls are crumbling.
- Just outside the 11-year-old facility, raw sewage bubbles from a broken septic
- system.
-
- At the similarly decrepit Ebeye Hospital, medical equipment breaks down and
- can't be fixed. An X-ray developer was idled when its wiring was gnawed by
- rats. A new hospital stands empty nearby. The Marshallese can't afford to open
- it.
-
- Inadequate preventive care has contributed to appalling health statistics. Life
- expectancy for men is 61 years, third worst among 15 Pacific Island
- populations. Infants die at rates five times that in American Samoa in the South
- Pacific. Women die of cervical cancer at 75 times the U.S. rate. Liver cancer
- kills men at 30 times the U.S. rate.
-
- There is no breast cancer screening because there is no mammography
- machine. Only after Marshallese women develop suspicious lumps are they
- flown 2,300 miles to Honolulu for a mammogram. Breast cancer kills at five
- times the U.S. rate.
-
- The Marshallese believe their suffering and sacrifice for U.S. nuclear weapons
- testing and America's continuing military presence at the strategic U.S. Army
- missile range at Kwajalein Atoll, entitle them to more U.S. help. Talks begin in
- 1999 on the extension of the Compact of Free Association, which defines the
- two countries' relationship.
-
- But U.S. officials express no interest in expanding the taxpayers' largess for
- what is now an independent country with a diminished strategic importance and
- a history of mismanaging previous aid.
-
- U.S. auditors have for years found evidence of waste and corruption in the
- islands. A Marshallese inquiry last year revealed millions of dollars in
- misappro- priations by top officials of the Marshallese Social Security
- Administration, who oversee the health care system.
-
- "The corruption here is so widespread that it is depressing," said Alan E.
- Hutchinson, administrator for the 177 Program, a U.S.-funded health care plan
- for residents of nuclear-contaminated atolls and their descendants. "It is no
- wonder that, as you look around you see so little tangible evidence of the
- massive U.S. aid we hear about."
-
- The health crisis in the Marshall Islands is invisible to the trickle of outsiders --
- about 6,000 each year -- who visit here for business or pleasure.
-
- Scuba divers fly 4 1/2 hours from Honolulu to explore the spectacular reefs, or
- World War II-era ships sunk by atomic bombs in 1946 at Bikini Atoll.
- Fishermen come for the deep-sea angling. A few war buffs seek relics of the
- 1944 fighting on Kwajalein and Enewetok that ended 30 years of Japanese
- rule.
-
- They find 29 delicate coral atolls and five tiny islands. Coconut palms,
- breadfruit and pandanus trees grow lush in the hot, humid weather and
- abundant rain -- 12 to 15 inches each month.
-
- The Marshalls' total dry land covers less than in Baltimore City. It speckles a
- region of the Pacific twice the size of Texas, just above the equator and west of
- the International Date Line. At noon in Baltimore, it is 4 a.m. the next day in
- the Marshalls.
-
- In 1947, the Marshalls became part of a U.N. Strategic Trust Territory in
- Micronesia under U.S. administration. The United States promised to promote
- their "economic advancement and self-sufficiency."
-
- Independence came in 1986. Under the 15-year Compact, the United States
- kept its base at Kwajalein. The islands received millions of dollars in annual
- aid, open immigration to the U.S. and access to federal programs such as Head
- Start and Pell college grants. The currency is the U.S. dollar.
-
- Birth rates are high, and half the population is under age 15. The children laugh
- and smile easily. Their parents are shy and modest, but friendly when
- approached by strangers. Most speak some English, in addition to Marshallese.
-
- The east end of Majuro -- a shoestring of an island 30 miles long, and 50 to a
- few hundred yards wide -- is the center of businesses and government. Its low,
- boxy buildings are strung along the island's bumpy, two-lane main road. Most
- of its 25,000 residents live on dirt lanes, in homes ranging from simple,
- air-conditioned block and stucco, to plywood shacks.
-
- Ebeye, 275 miles to the northwest, is far poorer. More than 13,000 people
- crowd the 85-acre island's dense neighborhoods of mostly plywood shacks.
-
- About 1,200 Ebeye residents commute two miles by water to jobs at the U.S.
- base on Kwajalein. The high-tech base is a well-ordered, but isolated
- community of 3,000 U.S. soldiers, defense contractors and their families.
- Kwajalein's vast lagoon is a target for missiles fired from California.
-
- Asked what has done the most damage to their health, most Marshallese will
- say it is the radioactive fallout from 12 years of atomic testing that ended in
- 1958. In February 1946 -- 18 months after the atomic attacks on Japan -- U.S.
- officials went before King Juda, the traditional leader on Bikini in the northern
- Marshalls.
-
- Navy Commodore Ben H. Wyatt, the military governor, asked Juda to move
- Bikini's 167 people for "the good of mankind and to end all world wars." The
- United States wanted a remote spot to test its developing atomic arsenal.
-
- King Juda deliberated, then agreed. If the United States wanted to use the
- islands for work that "with God's blessing will result in kindness and benefit
- to all mankind," he said, "my people will be pleased to go elsewhere."
-
- Their generosity was the start of a half-century of nuclear exile, and a
- continuing national tragedy.
-
- The atomic and hydrogen bombs triggered on Bikini and Enewetok -- with 100
- times the power of all the atmospheric tests in Nevada -- exploded in the air, on
- the ground, under water, on barges and balloons. Most of the radiation fell
- back on Bikini and Enewetok, or drifted north over the ocean. But not all.
-
- In February 1954, one of America's first hydrogen bombs was detonated
- before dawn on one of the Bikini atoll's ring of islands.
-
- But hours earlier, high altitude winds had shifted east, toward populated atolls
- 75 and 300 miles away. The Americans moved monitoring ships as a
- precaution, but no one thought it necessary to warn, much less evacuate, the
- Marshallese.
-
- The bomb, dubbed Castle BRAVO, exploded with the force of 15 million tons
- of TNT, or 1,000 Hiroshima bombs. It turned the islet into a crater 24 stories
- deep and 6,000 feet wide, and sent a debris cloud 114,000 feet into the sky.
-
- Radioactive dust fell on 28 U.S. weather observers on Rongerik Atoll, on 253
- residents of the Rongelap and Utrik atolls, and on 23 Japanese fishermen 90
- miles at sea. Within hours, most were suffering burns, nausea, diarrhea,
- itching, peeling skin, sores, lost hair and nails. One of the Japanese fishermen
- would be dead in seven months.
-
- Norio Kebinli, then 10, was up before dawn that morning, outside the
- cookhouse on Rongelap. "I saw a lightning," he said. "And after the lightning I
- saw a huge thing going up in the west. The color was yellow and orange."
- Then came a noise "like a big thunderstorm."
-
- Hours later, while climbing a papaya tree, he felt the radioactive dust falling
- into his eyes. The "snow" fell for hours. It landed on Kebinli's brother, Iroji,
- who was walking with girls on a beach. Iroji's burns were later photographed
- by U.S. military personnel. He died from a brain lesion eight years later.
-
- Kebinli, now 54, has burn scars on his left foot. One of his cousins, a year old
- in 1954, died in 1972 from radiation-induced leukemia.
-
- "I don't blame anybody," Kebinli said. "It was an accident."
-
- U.S. military press officers declared everyone safe, but American doctors
- began medical treatments and evacuated the two atolls. Authorities later offered
- cash and free medical care for any radiation-related illnesses among Rongelap
- and Utrik residents exposed by the BRAVO explosion.
-
- Doctors from the Brookhaven National Laboratory, under a $2.4 million
- annual contract to the Department of Energy, still make twice-yearly trips to the
- Marshalls to treat and study the exposed islanders, and compare their fates with
- an "unexposed" control group.
-
- Nearly 100 of the exposed have died, but Brookhaven's reports say the death
- rates are no higher than the control group's.
-
- BRAVO's greatest health impact, they say, has been thyroid disease, caused by
- the concentration of radioactive iodine in the thyroid gland, which regulates
- growth and metabolism.
-
- About a third of the Rongelap residents -- 79 percent of children aged 10 or
- under in 1954 -- developed growth retardation, thyroid nodules or cancers.
- Rates were lower on Utrik. All were treated with drugs or with surgery in U.S.
- hospitals. Brookhaven reported no thyroid cancer fatalities.
-
- In 1994, a non-U.S. scientific advisory panel told the Marshallese government
- that "some islands" in the four exposed atolls need decontamination before
- people can return. But elsewhere, they said, current levels of contamination
- "pose no risk of adverse health effects to the present generation."
-
- Authors of a Nationwide Radiological Study commissioned by the Marshallese
- said any continuing fear is based on ignorance, fueled by persistent press and
- scientific interest.
-
- "The main challenge," they said, "is in increasing the understanding of
- government leaders, health care workers, teachers, the media and the public
- about the true risks of radioactivity, and about the natural causes for cancer and